Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed.

So I will begin this by saying I am an unashamed Rock Band fanboy. Playing expert guitar and drums (and, when I'm feeling brave, vocals) is now one of my favored ways to listen to music and relax at the end of the day. I'll be in line for Beatles Rock Band on day one. I've written about how wrong-headed criticisms of these games are and how they are a cool, new way to appreciate music. Playing fake plastic drums is probably the most fun I've had with a video game, ever. I am one of the music game dead-enders.

Which is why it pains me so much to be the turd in the punchbowl. The fad is dying. Fast.

We all know it. We've all seen the glut. (What? Eight rhythm games out this year? Yikes!) It's the sure sign of trying to cash in on the installed base as much as possible before the fall. Sales for new Guitar Hero titles are, well, not encouraging.

If there could have been any question, the offer of a free Guitar Hero: Van Halen with purchase of Guitar Hero 5, before either of those games is even out, is the clearest sign you could possibly want. (This deal actually tempted me a little, until I realized that taking it would put me at risk of listening to Van Halen.)

The Beatles game will goose the genre a little, but even new releases with serious, broad appeal (Led Zeppelin? Pink Floyd?) will only slow the decay.

But, here's the thing. It's easy to blame the glut for the death of the fad, but, even if music games had been released at a reasonable pace, the thing was doomed to collapse. It wasn't sustainable, ever. I think it's interesting to look at why.

i. The Magic Wore Off

Now, most of this is based on my own personal observations and thus should be taken with a grain of salt. But isn't the magic gone? When Rock Band was new, I and two other friends frequently threw Rock Band parties, and they were well attended. Getting four people to pick up the plastic instruments was easy. Two years later? Not so much. I stopped throwing Rock Band parties after my last one, when I looked around during one song and realized I was the only one left playing. Everyone else had migrated to the next room. It was pathetic.

There is a certain sort of brain that has a compelling, all-consuming urge to hit those little colored spots as they come down the track. I have such a brain. But for everyone else, well, let's face it. Pressing the red button to hit the red light and the green button to hit the green light does not compelling gameplay make. It was a kick to do it a few evenings. Now it's done. Even a game for the Casual Market (tm) has to have SOMETHING to it.

ii. It Is An Expensive Activity ...

$249 for the full Beatles: Rock Band set. Again, yikes.

Happily, in an effort to avoid flaming suicide, it was just announced that there will be cheaper bundles available. And yet, MSRP of $160 is still pretty darn spendy.

iii. ... and Not Just In Cash

I'm talking about cost in resources. And my liberal leanings are going to show a little in the next paragraph, so be warned.

It takes a lot of resources to make these bulky instruments (especially drums), pack them up, ship them over the sea, get them to you, and, from there, dump them in landfills. A lot of plastic and oil in our new oil-short, global-warming reality. And, if this recession should have taught us anything, it's that we're going too much in debt buying too much useless crap from the Chinese. Something has got to go. And I think shoddy plastic Fisher Price drum kits will be first in line.

And, perhaps most significantly, these games consume a lot of space in stores. You want to know when there will be serious blood on the walls in the music game business? It'll be when some executive at Best Buy looks at the enormous amount of precious floor space taken up by big, bulky Rock Band and Guitar Hero boxes, remembers the sloping sales, and says, "Enough."

What Is the Future?

Of course, music games will remain a profitable little niche in this huge industry. Nothing that generates as many sales as Guitar Hero 3 had can ever disappear. But how will it evolve in a sustainable form?

First, games with vocals will always do all right. Microphones are small and easy to make. People love singing drunken karaoke. SingStar fans have nothing to worry about.

Guitar games will always survive. Fake plastic guitars are relatively small, flat, and easy to pack. Stores will always have a small section with two or three brands of plastic geetar. Borderline Asperger's cases like me will always have little, bright lights to hit.

Which brings us to my beloved drums. Harmonix did an amazing job of creating a mode of gameplay which sits interestingly in the shadow zone between video games and real instruments. Fake plastic drums are awesome. But let's face it. They're big. They're bulky. They don't last long under heavy use. (No cheap plastic toy will withstand being hit with a stick thousands of times.) And they aren't popular. The current mode of fake drum playing is just too tricky for the casual types these games need to live.

The drums will have to go. And when they do, band games will have to go too. Music games will fragment into singing games (for the many who love that) and guitar games (which two people can play, instead of four). Rock Band, if it survives, will still provide drum charts for the installed base. But in a few years, when we go to the next generation of consoles? Forget it.

And, someday, we will look back on the Great Music Game Fad and remember the glut of titles and the mountains of instruments at Best Buy and the $299 video game controller and go, "Wow, what was that all about?" and laugh and laugh and laugh.

93 comments:

  1. My agreement is uncharacteristically wholehearted. I am, however, biased, not having the sort of brain enthused by music themed Simon Says. My own failing, I suppose.

    ReplyDelete
  2. When I first heard about Rock Band having a drum controller, I figured it would be too bulky and expensive to last (as I expect a real drum set is if you aren't serious about it, and maybe even if you are). I just wonder how long it will be before technology makes video game drumming more viable, and how it will do so.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My first thought was to post something like, "but... DLC!" until I remembered that new songs will rarely be enough to bring party guests back in from the other room. Good post.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Stupid, expensive, controllers for video games are nothing new.

    Remember a little number called the Power Glove?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think you may have misspoken a bit. The era of buying expensive equipment with an extra drum or pedal is over, yes; However, it's the manufacturers killing themselves off, not the level of cannibalization in the market. What I mean by this is simple; by requiring users/players to purchase new hardware just to access the new content (read: songs), they are shooting themselves in the foot. The market for purchasing rockband songs online is still growing, and continues to grow as enhancements are constantly made to platform-specific content delivery engines (PSN).

    There is certainly something that gets old with playing Beastie Boys - Sabotage time after time again until the novelty wears off, however the approach to making money should be similar to Madden NFL's revenue model. Sure with a new release of madden brings *some* new features, but mostly the reason people are purchasing it is because of the content (new players/rosters).

    Rock Band needs to get away from releasing new, proprietary, costly equipment, and start moving more towards new content, delivered digitally.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Haha! Your "Rock Band Party" story is funny because a friend of mine kept throwing "Musician Parties" where a bunch of folks that play real instruments would go over and we'd jam out random stuff together. It was cool for a while, but eventually it didn't last 10 minutes until he was in the room by himself playing 'Freebird'. Again. While everyone else was off doing other stuff. Don't feel too bad Jeff!!

    It's interesting how you talk about the Drums going the way of the Dodo, because that actually mirrors the real music industry. There is a known, nationwide drummer shortage! I don't have any links, but a few years ago, there was actually an article about it in the Wall Street Journal! Everyone wants to be a guitarist or singer, and it's no surprise to me that drums would be the first to feel the crunch in band game. A minimum real drumset is a crapload more expensive than a minimal guitar rig. Hell, in a lot of circles, you don't even have to own a microphone to be able to call yourself a singer!

    I had a friend that was a sales rep for Ludwig Drums years back, and I thought that drums sales had to be terrible considering circumstances, but he said Nay! Drum companies actually sell boatloads of drumsets, but they sell most of them to folks with careers in their later 30s or 40s that have no interest in actually playing in a band, they just want to beat the crap out of studff in their basement! I was shocked, but I guess he was the expert. Maybe that's why you like Rock Band drums so much! Same effect costing far less money and making far less racket?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think the technology will continue to evolve, although the game may change faces and become less casual. I can imagine a keyboard instrument in the near future, and a guitar that is more realistic (say, with strings).

    Think of that - a guitar game that, when played, actually makes you better at guitar!

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Technomancer

    Clearly then, the solution to the lack of a drummer in one's band is best solved by approaching as many middle aged salary men as possible!

    Actually, just five of those guys all drumming would be an amazing band.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The handheld versions will always remain cheap and easy to produce.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @Technomancer: That story made me laugh.

    "It's interesting how you talk about the Drums going the way of the Dodo, because that actually mirrors the real music industry. There is a known, nationwide drummer shortage! "

    The main effect Rock Band has had on me personally is a deep and surprising regret that I didn't learn to play the drums when I was young.

    - Jeff Vogel

    ReplyDelete
  11. Or guitar, for that matter.

    Great article, thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm not sure I totally follow the logic here. $240 for the Beatles game doesn't sound sustainable -- sure -- but if you already have the fake instruments, you can get the game alone for under $60. And plenty of people do already have the instruments.

    The bit about Van Halen made me laugh. Especially since I went through a similar thought process. And yet, any game that would consider me getting Van Halen for the music has got to have something very powerful going for it.

    My guess is that these games have only scratched the surface. They'll improve in breadth (more songs) and depth (more creative aspects added, so you're not merely a parrot). The bottom line is that music is meaningful to many of us and there is a huge market here.

    ReplyDelete
  13. @Thomas: Like I said though, they don't really have any interest in being in a band, even part time. Alien thinking to me, but to each their own. The real solution is drum programming. Just need to somehow make it cool to play on stage with a laptop instead of a drummer.

    @Jeff: It's never too late man! Wanna join my band? lol!

    I think everyone should learn an instrument, at least for just private enjoyment, but I'm biased.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Jeff, you're borderline Aspie? Neat! Me too. Rock on and prosper.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm upset of the lack of DDR mentions in your music game posts. :(

    ReplyDelete
  16. There will surely be more services like http://www.karaokeparty.com in the future, especially when the computer moves into the tv.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The cool thing is, I'm just now getting into it.

    I guess that means lots of cheap used copies for me! It's so awesome being behind the times in situations like this.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I disagree that the drums are not popular round here thats the main instrument. Im not bothered about the guitar at all. the new games should just be downloaded content maybe.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I am not into music, but if I'm listening the soundtrack of Download Games I play, I appreciate every bit of sound. I don't know perhaps because it gives me somewhat like motivation to level up on games.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I was looking and reading other articles about Rock Band. Guitar Hero. Why They Are Doomed, and yours is the one with the most interesting info. Thanks for sharing and have a nice day.


    generic viagra

    ReplyDelete
  21. I would like to work with Rock band
    because I love to play guitar.


    ..Alex

    Purchase
    viagra online

    ReplyDelete
  22. I better play real guitard (even if I'm a very bad player) than playing like a rockstar in those games !

    Robert from t-shirt rap

    ReplyDelete
  23. 2010 Winter coming , are you going to present Moncler down jackets Sale for your families . Shop for the classic bady Women coats from Moncler , Moncler men jackets are also available

    ReplyDelete
  24. Information abouth the Douduone Moncler :
    Moncler have been thought as one of the most popular jackets brand in the world today.

    Doudoune Moncler Femme serait votre meilleur choix pour cet hiver en résistant au froid si. Maintenant, Moncler doudoune vous permettra de renoncer au tissu épais. En hiver, vous pouvez montre aussi votre silhouette élégante.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Moncler is a luxury and fashion brand since 1952 when it was created in the French town of Monestier de Clermont. Moncler jackets men sponsored the official uniform of the French team in the 1968 Grenoble Olympics. Moncler jacket reputation received a further boost in the 1980s when the brand became hugely popular in Italy. The high end brand is world famous for its quilted down jackets, ski and outer wear clothing line.The Moncler jackets have been becoming a style item that everyone must have.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Oh my!!! You are just too true to be good. How do you manage to write and research on such wonderful things? You have inspired me to work harder now. I shall try as much as possible to enjoy life to the fullest and be satiated with the wonderful things that are around me, which I have been unaware of until now.turbulence training review

    ReplyDelete
  27. I really enjoyed a lot ,I shall try as much as possible to enjoy , logo design

    ReplyDelete
  28. Although i’m no n00b in the website industry, your site really is something different and features some helpful thoughts… Enjoying it to the fullest! I’ll incorporate you in my blogroll, i think it will provide more value to my visitors. New SUV Car, Hybrid Car Specifications, Keep healthy naturally, berita indonesia

    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. Keep posting.
    Facebook Clone Script| Groupon Clone Script| PHP Scripts|

    ReplyDelete
  30. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how can we communicate?
    Hotels In Palermo

    ReplyDelete
  31. I Am Sure.... You are just too true to be good. How do you manage to write and research on such wonderful things? You have inspired me to work harder now. I shall try as much as possible to enjoy life to the fullest and be satiated with the wonderful things that are around me, which I have been unaware of until now.
    Dripping Springs Remodeling Company

    ReplyDelete
  32. The good news to tell you. Now our People have the chance to enjoy the gucci tote bags easily. All kinds of ralph lauren outlet and cheap true religion jeansare arrival in gucci boston bags shop. Just a small ammount of money could help you to share gucci sukey bags perfect. I like to buy these two kinds of ralph lauren polo shirts: One is ralph lauren classic fit, the other is cheap designer shoes. cheap true religion jeans and cheap designer handbags are loved by all of my friends.
    I heard louis gucci baby bags is a highly qualified shop. Good quality of the goods inside, the price not expensive. Such as gucci joy bags, is a good example of very good-looking style. People like cheap coach handbags, which is your preferred store, but this time is in the discount period. Hurried over and look down, Do not miss this opportunity.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Nice post! Thanks for sharing!
    Generic Levitra

    ReplyDelete
  34. Jeannie--Thank you for the nice compliment! This is definitely one of those fun books to have around for not only visual inspiration, but for some great nuts and bolts how-to as well...
    Abilene Roofing Contractor

    ReplyDelete
  35. You have a very good blog that the main thing a lot of interesting and useful!
    bondage sex video

    ReplyDelete
  36. I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.

    the best seo company

    ReplyDelete
  37. I think they are doomed because they are not responsible for their actions. . .very interesting site. . thanks for sharing it to us. .

    phone spy software for the safety of my phone.Android phone locator for the tracking of my location.
    android gps apps locator and tracking my route.

    android tracker also a tracker for my gps.

    gps tracking
    gps track cell phone
    cell tracker software
    mobile phone locator
    track cell phone location
    parental control phone
    cell phone parental control software

    ReplyDelete
  38. nice post, music is the food for the soul. thanks for posting.

    credit repair houston

    ReplyDelete
  39. href="http://www.frogheatingandair.com/">Nashville Heating"

    We are your reliable heating and air conditioning service company serving Nashville and surrounding cities. Mike and I (Denissa) Morgan have successfully provided home electrical services for the Greater Nashville area since 1998.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping

    the same best work from you in the future as well.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I liked the posts and cool layout you have here! I would like to thank you for sharing your experience and the time it took to post!! Two Thumbs up!

    Tubal Reversals | Tubal Ligation reversal Surgery

    ReplyDelete
  42. El blog está escrito de tal manera que es muy fácil de leer y entender.


    nutricionista Barcelona | dietista Barcelona | dietas Barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  43. organic vitamins

    You will be missed.The one place where as a venue and fan I could search by
    what ever perimeters I chose .Good Luck with your future endeavors.

    organic vitamins

    ReplyDelete
  44. This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information.



    buy curcumin

    ReplyDelete
  45. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping

    the same best work from you in the future as well.

    central playa hotel ibiza

    ReplyDelete
  46. testimonial voiceovers


    Very significant article for us ,I think the representation of this article is
    actually superb one. This is my first visit to your site

    testimonial voiceovers

    ReplyDelete
  47. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping

    the same best work from you in the future as well.

    Hotels in Santa Eulalia

    Ibiza

    ReplyDelete
  48. Really you have done great job, there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post. I like this blog... ~^- organic supplements -^~

    ReplyDelete
  49. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping

    the same best work from you in the future as well.

    <a href="http://365healthinsurance.com/texas/>Texas Health Insurance</a>

    ReplyDelete
  50. Información muy útil que tenemos aquí, me gusta mucho la forma en que está escrito.

    dietista Barcelona | dietas Barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  51. This is my first visit here. I found some really interesting stuff in your blog especially this discussion. Keep up the good work.
    find doctors list

    doctor ratings and reviews

    ReplyDelete
  52. This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best
    bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative article.


    3d ultrasounds
    4d ultrasounds
    4d3d ultrasounds

    ReplyDelete
  53. I would never have thought of re-creating spaghetti-0's, but I'll bet the grandkids will love them.

    weight loss spray
    naturalsleep aid
    sleep aidsupplement
    sleep aid spray
    Appetite Control spray

    ReplyDelete
  54. These kind of post are always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post, writing is simply great, thank you for the post.

    tubal reversal surgery | reversal of tubal ligation

    ReplyDelete
  55. Nice stuff you got, very interesting to read.Well, I do have also in my sleeves, if you have

    time don't forget to visit

    Hotel lanzarote

    ReplyDelete
  56. University Medical Center in Carolina, has suggested that curcumin, found in the popular curry ingredient tumeric, could help prevent the onset of dementia


    curcumin
    buy curcumin

    ReplyDelete
  57. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
    health insurance california

    ReplyDelete
  58. Nice stuff you got, very interesting to read.
    Well, I do have also in my sleeves, if you have time don't forget to visit
    Frases

    ReplyDelete
  59. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping

    the same best work from you in the future as well.

    bandar bola

    ReplyDelete
  60. Your blog is outstanding! I mean, I have never been so entertained by anything in my life! Thanks for sharing such a nice post.
    24 hour locksmiht

    ReplyDelete
  61. I have never been so entertained by anything in my life!
    uk dissertation help

    ReplyDelete
  62. You want to know when there will be serious blood on the walls in the music game business?
    dissertation help

    ReplyDelete
  63. Mostly in referrals to my mature dissertation, but I would like to explore the restrictions before publishing my viewpoint. I motivate others to so as well.

    Compra Oro Plata

    ReplyDelete
  64. the website is pleasing me in the right way. I hope new posts will come soon. modern seo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It’s a great site to see. That will help for improvisation of me. Will definitely marked as Bookmark.

      business phone providers

      Delete
  65. I’m so pleased that I took a chance to look at your blog, because let me tell you. Not a lot of individuals know how to stability information of a topic and articles Free Categorized Ads.electromagnetic radiation

    ReplyDelete
  66. Thanks for sharing this great Post dude
    SEO Services in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  67. friv games 2018 is new flash games which are expected to be the best Friv 4 games to play. You can find all game Friv 4 school free in Friv 2018 and Friv 4 School .Friv 2018 is one of the number one websites that offers thousands of exciting games around the world with high quality. Here, you can search for games in any category. We guarantee that your satisfaction is our pleasure.

    tủ nấu cơm
    máy làm Ðá

    ReplyDelete
  68. Your blog is really excellent. It inspires the readers who have that great desire to lead a better and happier life. Thanks for sharing this information and hope to read more from you. Great information…



    Tubemate download for android 2018 free
    Download Tubemate for Android Free
    How to Download YouTube Videos from Tubemate 2018

    ReplyDelete
  69. After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.

    Click Here
    Producthunt.com

    ReplyDelete
  70. I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!…

    Website
    Information

    ReplyDelete
  71. When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

    Website
    Information
    Click Here

    ReplyDelete
  72. Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from youjogos io
    jogos friv online
    Jogos live
    jogos friv 4 school

    ReplyDelete

  73. Fast cash offer for you today at just 2% interest rate, both long and short term cash of all amounts and currencies, no collateral required. We give out from a minimum range of $2000 to a maximum of $20 million.We are certified and your privacy is 100% safe with us Apply now for your instant approval and transfer approval process takes just 3 hours. contact us now
    I'll advise you can contact us via email at
    Contact Us At : abdullahibrahimlender@gmail.com
    whatspp Number +918929490461
    Mr Abdullah Ibrahim

    ReplyDelete
  74. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Cheap dissertation writing services

    ReplyDelete
  75. idn poker situs judi online dengan berbagai macam permainan seperti ceme keliling, super10, omaha dan masih banyak lagi permainan yang dapat menguntungkan anda dalam bermain judi online setiap hari, anda minimal deposit 10 ribu saja untuk bermain di idn poker dengan berbagai macam keuntungan dan banyak bonus yang bisa di dapatkan, ayo klik link di bawah ini untuk bermain di idn poker.
    http://online.education.cm/forums/user/situsidnpokeronline/

    ReplyDelete
  76. idn poker situs judi online yang sudah menjadi pilihan banyak pemain di indonesia untuk bermain judi karena bisa dapat keuntungan dengan mudah dan cepat setiap hari bermain di idn poker, hanya dengan modal 10 ribu anda sudah bisa bermain di idn poker. ayo klik link di bawah ini untuk bermain di idn poker.
    https://yose.com.ar/forums/user/situsidnpokeronline/

    ReplyDelete
  77. Grate article, We at Addhunters shifted this service to a level much higher than the broker concept. you can see more details like this article Property for sale For sale in lusail

    ReplyDelete
  78. Thankyou for giving me useful information.
    Please keep posting.
    사설토토
    바카라사이트

    ReplyDelete
  79. Nice post. Thanks for sharing. The best. Like it very much. 123สล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  80. This is the first time that I visit here. I found so many exciting matters in this particular blog, One thing I would like to request you that pls keep posting such type of informative blog.
    Site: Cosplay Jackets store

    ReplyDelete
  81. HARDCORE CYCLES was started in the Greater Philadelphia area by a group of tight friends with a passion for V-Twin performance aftermarket parts.

    Arlen ness

    ReplyDelete
  82. Your blog post on Rock Band and Guitar Hero was an interesting read. On another note, finding the right doctor can be challenging. Meri Sehat's online medical services offer a convenient doctor finder platform that can help people find the right medical professional to manage their health conditions. Their services are invaluable, and I appreciate the convenience they offer. Keep up the great work, Meri Sehat!

    ReplyDelete