Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Surviving In the Post-Indie Bubble Wasteland!!!

Incendiary title. Check. Dramatic image. Check. Time to sit back and let the retweets roll in!
A couple of weeks ago, I wrote a widely read and mostly acclaimed article about the popping of what I termed the "Indie Bubble." I promised to write more about what I thought was coming and how I thought a small-scale creative artist could make a living in the times to come. It’s a long piece, and boring, so I’ll try to slip in a fart joke somewhere to keep things lively.

Although I'll be focused on video games, I flatter myself by thinking that the things I have to say apply to creators in all sorts of media.

Quite a few people, publicly and privately, asked for my advice and for my opinion on where things go from here. And I think it is solid evidence of how unpredictable and gut-emptyingly terrifying things have gotten that anyone thinks it useful to ask for my opinion.

Look, I don't know what's going to happen next. I'm not a sorceror. I approach these blog posts like Seal Team Six. I sneak in over the border, plant my bombs, and get out.

Plus, I'm old. I keep mentioning how old I am. Folks, this is not a boast. It's a warning. This whole mess is in the hands of the next generation, who grew up with their bleepy bloopy devices and have an intuitive grasp of them I never will.

I went to see a rock show the other week and these two kids in front of me (kids = people in their 20s) used Instagram, followed by SnapChat, followed by three apps that, I don't even know what they were, and it was like watching the birth of a new species. These people shouldn't be listening to me about anything.

I don't know what is next. But I'm not useless. One thing my weird endurance in indie games has given me is a very fine understanding of the advantages of "being indie." What makes people like us, what keeps us around, why we are needed, and how we can turn that into money. (I like money. It can be exchanged for goods and services.)

(Oh, and by the way, lots of people objected to my use of the word "bubble." Here is why I called it the Indie "Bubble." Because I knew if I did, many more people would read the post. It worked. Ha ha.)

So come with me! Let us, in the spirit of Christmas Specials of olde, learn the True Meaning of Indie.

In the future, young indie developers will have to fight in the Thunderdome. Winners get a 300 word preview in Kotaku.
The Term 'Indie' Is Useless

People in all media argue ceaselessly about what "indie" means. It's a sublime waste of time. Silly eggheads! Indie means whatever you want it to mean.

Indie is a type of business. It's a type of funding. It's a marketing term. In fact, the term ‘indie’ can mean everything but a type of game. Calling a game an "indie game" is like buying a six-pack of beer on sale and offering it to your friends as "on-sale-beer."

"Indie" describes the manner of its making, not the game itself. But you're the customer. You don't care how the sausage was made, only that it's sizzling on the plate and won't give you a case of the gutworms. So, in this sense, the term "indie game" is stupid and useless.

That's a Lie. You Know It. I Know It.

Everything in the previous section was wrong. You can feel it in your gut, next to the worms you got from the sausages. Yet if you try to explain why, you'll get tangled up in words, because you're trying to quantify art, and that is unpossible.

When humans say "Indie," whether in games or film or music, they are describing a quality that is completely intangible and yet entirely real. They are describing the feeling that the creation in question feels like authentic communication from another human being.

What makes my little RPGs "indie"? It's that, when you play them, you can feel the presence of my brain behind them, and you know that I cared. When you play, say, Avernum, you are spending some time living in the world as I saw it when I wrote it.

This quality is not restricted simply to games that intend to be art. My favorite example here is AaaaaAAaaaAAAaaAAAAaAAAAA!!! for the Awesome, a game you really should try. It's a simple arcade game, and yet it is written with a very peculiar, hilarious, distinctive aesthetic that makes one feel, after a time, like one is visiting the creators' brains. (If you try it, play levels until you start to unlock the funny videos. You'll know them when you reach them.)

It is possible for an independently produced game to not feel at all Indie. iTunes is full of this. Similarly, it is possible for a big-budget AAA game to feel super-indie. (Insert Saints Row IV plug here.)

You are creating something for people. To affect them. To take one of many possible routes into their brains. We're toymakers, and it's an awesome thing to be. This is the Goal.

Advice #1: Make the thing you care about, and people will sense it. If you make something you don't believe in because you think it'll make more money, players will smell the stink of desperation on you.

And yet, "indie" is almost always applied in the context of small, scrappy, hungry developers. There is a very good reason for that, which you ignore at your peril.

The facts: Most people want this. This will sell more than you. But people need to know that they have choices besides this.
Our Greatest Advantage!!!

Our biggest advantage is that people like us. They want us to succeed.

Small game developers fit the archetype of the lone tinkerer, slaving late into the night, creating because they are driven to create, damn the consequences.

In my culture, at least, this is a truly powerful and beloved archetype, one buried deep in the cultural and professional DNA of our society. When people see you as a driven tinkerer, rich in drive and creativity if not in wealth, they will want you to succeed. It is then a short jump to actively helping you to succeed.

As long as they like you. (But more on that later.)

Indie games will have their ups and downs, but they will always be around, because people will always be driven to make toys, success be damned. And there will always be profit in that, because some people will be determined to make them succeed, because they can't stand to live in a world where the little guy can't make it.

Advice #2: Never forget that people want to root for you, and be someone they'll want to root for. When your survival is necessary for the psychic health of others, that’s good.

Pictured: The indie ideal.
An Instructive Example

When I saw the game Octodad: Dadliest Catch at PAX a couple years ago, I had to write about it. Note, I've never played it. I only watched a few seconds of it. That was enough for me to know it'd be a success.

It's a game where you play an intelligent octopus with a human wife and children, and you have to perform tasks without them realizing you are not a human too. Much of the fun comes from the imprecise controls, which make your character flop all over the place in a humorous, destructive way.

Yeah, it's bonkers. What made me sure it'd do well is this: There are a lot of people who would buy it because they wanted to see a game like that be a success. (See also: Goat Simulator.)

To be clear, the quality that brings this sort of support is not humor or novelty. Your game doesn't have to be wacky or gimmicky or hentai-scented to succeed. (Though humor can help a LOT.) It just has to feel personal. Being in some way surprising is also helpful.

But again, this all depends on people wanting you to succeed, which means they have to like you, and they have to keep liking you. So you should know how to manage that.

Heading Out On the Path

OK, here's the usual scenario. You're passionate about games (or music, writing,  acting, etc). You've been doing it as a hobbyist for years, and that's awesome. Creating things as a hobbyist is a noble activity. All those famous designers you look up to? Practically all of them were writing games for years before they made the one you heard of. It takes ten years to make an overnight success.

But you've been doing it for a while, and now you have a hot idea. You think you can turn it into money. You want to Go Pro.

Now, before, I always gave the advice to look for an underserved niche and serve it. I kind of have to take that back. One of the tough things about the glut of indie games is that the number of underserved niches has gone way down. As I write this, Steam is getting a new RPG a DAY. So many. Does this worry me, a writer of RPGs? Hell yes. But I write RPGs for a living. It's all I'm good for. So, even if I see a sexy new market somewhere else, I have to die on this hill.

Inspiration strikes where it strikes, and individual creative processes are very important. Write what you care about, even if it's another 2-D platformer. If you like to work alone, work alone. If you need to be part of a team, do that. If you don't mind doing things on the cheap (like using stock art and music), that can work. If you need perfect professional work for everything, that's what you need to do. (But be prepared to pay the price.)

Advice #3: Figure out what your process is, and then respect and defend it.
How the game industry sees me. "Golly! Is that one them new-fangled computer thing-a-ma-bobs? Gosh!"
So You Have a Dream and a Process

You're working on your game. You believe in it. There is a subset of gamers, maybe large, maybe small, that you can look dead in the eye and say, "You HAVE to try my game. It will change your life." (If you can't honestly do this, you need to go back a step or two.)

Now you need to write it, and you need to sell it. To do this and make money at the end, you need to keep two key variables in mind: PR and Budget. The reason I am writing this article is that the way of dealing with these variables is rapidly changing.

First, there is how much PR you can get. Word of mouth. Web site articles. YouTube videos. You NEED some PR, to start the word of mouth at least, and you need to be realistic about how much you can get.

Some people misinterpreted the end of my indie bubble article to mean I thought that indie games would die out and there would be no more hits. Of course, this is ludicrously far from what I was saying. Their have to be hits. Journalists need hit games to write about. Steam and iTunes need to make hits to sell. Gamers need hits to buy. Some games will always get the golden PR ticket, because the system demands it. The problem now is that, to get the attention, the number of rivals you have to elbow in the throat is WAY higher.

(Yes, I just said that Steam and Apple make hits. If they decide they just want to make a game a hit, they can give it great placement. This phenomenon happens in many media. We've been lucky so far in that the games chosen to be hits are generally good. This will not always be so.)

Here's the key point about the PR. If your game is really good, you'll get word of mouth. With work and press releases, you can get more on top of that. You need to estimate how much press you can get, and adjust your budget accordingly.

Consider Spiderweb Software. We do our games on the cheap, and, as a result, we don't need to get a lot of press to make a solid living. Most people don't want to take our route, but you should know it's open to you. If it was necessary to go to conventions to get enough attention to survive, Spiderweb Software would not exist. I'm just not good at working the crowd.

Advice #4: Do PR or die. I don't know what you should do, but you need to do SOMETHING.

Then, Budget

After you know what sort of attention you can get, figure out how much you can afford to spend on your game. I don't have a lot to say about this. If you're SURE you need a hot big-name musician to score your game, hey, that's your process. My opinion is unimportant.

Just remember that every 5% you shave off the cost of making your game gives you a 5% better chance of business survival. Just make sure that 5% is worth it.

Me, I live cheap. I'm a bottom feeder. I'm merciless about reusing assets from game to game. Rendering creatures in Poser instead of getting a pricey freelancer. Buying cheap, royalty-free sounds. We sell detailed, interesting stories, written in nice, cheap text, and skimp on everything else.

We're so cheap that sometimes, at conventions, other developers make fun of me TO MY FACE. If you know how generally cordial indie developers try to be to each other, this is worth noting.

Most indie developers would rather throw their computers into a fire than release products with my level of polish. But I have a plan. I intend to retire in this business, and I will do what it takes to make it happen.

Advice #5: Don't forget that the best reason to go indie is that you get to do things your own way.

How you want your audience to see you.
On Being Likable

Seriously, the greatest advantage indie creators have is that people naturally sympathize with us and want us to succeed. Play to your strength, and remember, every time you act like a jerk in public, you're hurting all of us.

Cultivate a FRIENDLY personal relationship with customers whenever possible. Answer e-mails. Be present and engage users on forums in a friendly way as much as you can stand. Try to make a demo available so users can make sure your game will work before they pay for it. (I haven't been good about this lately, and I regret it.) Give refunds. Give advice. Use smilies. Be a nice person.

If you do a Kickstarter or Steam Early Access, be damn sure to live up to your promises, or give the users a timely, informative reason why you didn't. Doing otherwise hurts all of us.

Do your best to say yes to REASONABLE requests. It's OK to say 'no,' though. It's your game, your baby. Sometimes, you have to live up to your own ideals, even though you'll get a lot of undeserved hate for it. Here's a good example.

How you don't want your audience to see you.
Don't Look Sauron In the Eye

Conversely, if someone is mean to your game on some stupid forum somewhere, never ever engage them, attack them, argue why they're wrong, whatever. Nothing good has even come out of doing this. Ever. Some people won't like your game, or they won't like your face. Let. It. Go.

Here's a rule that I have violated many, many times, and I've always regretted it: If you must go out in public and air your edgy opinions, remember that goodwill is like money, and you are spending it. It is very easy to cross the line from being a positive archetype (sincere, small creator) to a very negative one (dour, humorless, judgmental blowhard).

This is one of the reasons I wrote the article a few weeks ago defending mobile games. If you are the hip indie developer who lectures gamers about what they should or should not want, you will make them defensive. Then they will get angry. At all of us.

Obviously, I'm not saying you should never say anything. Goodwill is money, and money doesn't do any good if you don't spend it. Just learn from my mistakes. People like us much better when we come forward in a spirit of being friendly, accepting, and eager to help.

Advice #6: Be nice and humble.

I Still Don't Know Where the Game Industry Is Going

Nope. Nobody does. No idea. This whole medium is completely new and without precedent. Nobody knows anything.

But there are some things that always work. Creativity. Determination. Believing in yourself. Working hard. A bit of luck. Kindness. Humility.

The bubble has popped, but we'll keep going on. As long as we make sure to embody the right set of ideals, gamers will refuse to let us fail.

57 comments:

  1. The optimistic point of view after the last post; Very general tips, but all of them true.

    I've been creating pencil & paper RPGs, graphic adventure games, graphics for free games, etc, for ten years now. I have to look to my professional future, and it's time to TRY to make some profit. Maybe this will go good or will go bad, but I'll try. I have this giantic RPG universe waiting to see the light in a better or worse PC-Game adaptation, and I'll don't stop until I published that, and if I have to end working at McNuggets, so be it!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I adore your writing, Jeff*. You got me through my first child with The Poo Bomb and damned if you're not going to get me through the indie bubble as well.

    * except for the errant 'their'. Good luck finding it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. get gud
    http://kotaku.com/how-a-seemingly-impossible-game-is-possible-1592820595

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As Tom Chick pointed out at Quartertothree, No Man's Sky is all things to all people. These breathless previews are building a mountain of expectations that will be difficult to fulfil.

      http://www.quartertothree.com/fp/2014/06/16/10-things-learned-e3-2014-draft/

      Delete
    2. Yes, everytime I see a kickstarter/indiegogo creating the ultimate terraria with planet colonization, or a sanbox with everything a man can ever imagined to play, the result is nothing... Luck to this Man's Sky!

      Delete
  4. Thanks a lot for taking the time to write this! Absolutely loved it, and you've inspired me to do better.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yeah, thanks Jeff, enjoying article!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Where's the fart joke? You promised a fart joke! I want my money back! :P

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm only five years younger then you, Jeff. You calling yourself old all the time makes me feel so... well, OLD. :p

    ReplyDelete
  8. Heartwarming.

    That sounds sarcastic, but it isn't. I hope this combination of realism and optimism is spot on. Makes me feel like maybe I can actually pull this indie game dev thing off!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Another great dev blog, thank you. I couldn't help but to post your Thunderdome quip to my Facebook - does that make me an official fan?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Minecraft cards unique codes are limited consequently speed how to get free minecraft premium account

    ReplyDelete
  11. "Seriously, the greatest advantage indie creators have is that people naturally sympathize with us and want us to succeed."

    This may be true in your experience, but it is generally not the case for women, queers, and people of color.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dünyanın en büyük erotik sektörü xnxx'in eline geçmiş bulunuyor.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your article is very interesting, and I think a lot of visitors who come to see your blog ...

    Obat kanker otak stadium 1

    Pengobatan epilepsi

    Obat diabetes melitus

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi I am so grateful I found your blog, I really found you by mistake, while I was looking on Bing for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say cheers for a remarkable post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read through it all at the minute but I have saved it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the fantastic work.
    don't forget visit this my web : Obat Kekentalan Darah | Cara Alami untuk Menyembuhkan Bronkitis | Obat Limfadenitis
    Thank you very much has been sharing this information very helpfull

    ReplyDelete
  15. You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.
    www.nationalbubblesoccer.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here.
    www.nationalbubblesoccer.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you for the information , I wait for more information and I ask for a return visit our new website
    >> Obat pembesar penis <<

    ReplyDelete
  18. Exceilent blog you have here but I was curious abou t if you knew of any communi ty forums tha t cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuaIs that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it....

    ReplyDelete
  19. I consider you. This post is actually exalting. i prefer your post and everything you share with United States of America is current and extremely informative, i would like to bookmarker the page therefore I will come back here from you that you simply have done an incredible job. Agen Sbobet Online Taruhan Bola Online

    ReplyDelete
  20. I know where I'm going and l know the truth, and I don't have to be what you want me to be. I'm free to be what I want.Thankyou i really love it. .

    ReplyDelete
  21. thanks for sharing that, I really liked this part of the article, with a nice and interesting topics have helped a lot of people who do not challenge things people should know... you need more publicize this so many people who know about it are rare for people to know this, Success for you. firefox offline

    ReplyDelete
  22. jeff - vogel give very good information . to give knowledge to me . thank you jeff - vogel .
    sorry i of Indonesia would like to share their knowledge about health , can be found here :
    obat untuk penyakit katarak
    obat untuk penyakit maag
    obat untuk nyeri sendi
    cara mengobati katarak
    cara mengobati sakit sendi
    Obat Flek Paru-Paru
    cara mengobati penyakit tbc
    cara mengobati kelenjar getah bening
    cara mengobati penyakit jantung
    Thank you. Hope it is useful.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Obat Kuat
    Thanks for the information , we will wait for the latest information on this blog , our greetings
    Obat Pembesar Penis | Ciri Vimax Asli

    ReplyDelete
  24. good morning and good luck spirit? Thank you for the information
    Vig Power Capsule Price Harga

    ReplyDelete
  25. Excellent blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it softtonice | canon support | drivers and software

    ReplyDelete
  26. Excellent blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it softonice | canon support | drivers and software

    ReplyDelete
  27. This article is very useful for those who are reading it, it's a shame if people skip reading. I also have articles that may be beneficial, as this article: obat puru-puru cara menurunkan asam lambung obat tradisional mata minus dan mata plus or also this article: cara mengobati nyeri sendi cara memulihkan patah tulang I believe it would be useful. and which is also very useful to increase knowledge obat benjolan di ketiak
    cara mengobati maag cara mengobati batu ginjal may be useful thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  28. woow cool article, no one else I spend the time to read and see-saw this article, I may take a little longer to read. good luck. but should not I share information such as the following information penyebab kemandulan cara mengobati gejala stroke pengobatan The article is an article that discusses the health problems of the body. cara menyembuhkan maag kronis cara menyembuhkan katarak The article just now is also the same article, but there is a solution for treatment. gejala cara mengobati kanker payudara gejala cara menyembuhkan usus buntu Articles such as this I created to share information that might be useful for everyone obat gangguan fungsi hati cara mempercepat proses pembakaran lemak I created because I wanted to give something to someone else that might be useful. And indeed for mengapai that is all I have to try harder.

    ReplyDelete

  29. Well, the post is pretty impressive and it is glad to read this posting

    newsbbc.net

    ReplyDelete
  30. It is in reality a great and helpful piece of info.
    I’m satisfied that you just shared this helpful information with us.
    Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.
    Destroy Windows 10 Spying Keygen

    ReplyDelete
  31. Mate this is a very nice blog here. I wanted to comment & say that I enjoyed reading your posts & they are all very well written out. You make blogging look easy lol I’ll attemp to start a blog later today and I hope it’s half as good as your blog! Much success to you!
    Dewa Joker.com
    Dewajoker.com
    www.dewajoker.com
    Dewa Joker.com
    Dewajoker.com

    ReplyDelete
  32. very helpful for reader and get more information here, and i found this blog good infomation and sharing about all

    brother mfc 8860dn driver

    ReplyDelete
  33. When you're tired, you want to relax after a stressful working hours, you need to have time to take care of the kids active.
    Please visit our website and play exciting flash games.
    Thanks you for sharing!
    Friv 4

    ReplyDelete
  34. Very nice information, a lot of important things that I get after seeing this article,,
    this information is really quite remarkable cool (y)

    Obat Kardiomegali Manfaat Coklat untuk Kesehatan dan Kecantikan Kulit Penyebab Penyakit Jantung Koroner Obat Herbal Radang Paru-Paru Obat Radang Usus Herbal

    ReplyDelete
  35. The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas
    of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.
    earn to die 3| earn to die 6
    earn to die 5| happy wheels
    strike force heroes| slitherio
    earn to die 5| good game empire |tank trouble 2 | earn to die 3

    ReplyDelete
  36. The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought you have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention. Berita Agen Bola Judi Bola Online Berita Agen Bola

    ReplyDelete
  37. Your website content nice nice and interesting to observe. I love and admire you
    Obat Flek Paru Paru

    ReplyDelete
  38. Welcomes to google terminal from Austin Texas! google snake
    Amazing insight you have on this, Happy wheels it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists... Age of war 2 This article always blew me... Earn to die For how many times I have read this.
    slither io Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while slitherio it's nice to find a website that details so much big farm

    ReplyDelete
  39. سعودي انحراف
    شات سعودي
    سعودي كام
    شات صوتي
    سعودي انحراف
    غلا الروح
    بنت مون
    شات قلبي الصوتي
    شات احلي كام
    سعودي توب
    شات جرحي
    زين كام
    سعودي كام
    شات صوتي
    سعودي انحراف
    صيف كام
    سعودي كول
    شات صوتي
    سعودي انحراف
    سعودي توب
    شات خليجي
    شات يتويب
    شات عفناك
    شات صوت العرب
    سعودي انحراف 180
    سعودي كام
    سعودي انحراف
    --------------

    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/saudisan7raf.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/glaroh.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/blog-post_27.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/qlpe.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/a7lacam.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/sauditop.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/jro7i.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/zaincam.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com
    http://www.chat-saudi.com
    http://www.chat-saudi.com
    http://www.chat-saudi.com
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/p/2019-saudi-cool.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/p/blog-page_30.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/Saudi-en7raf.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/sauditop.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/l77.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/youtubechat.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/3fnak.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com/2016/08/3rb-v.html
    http://www.chat-saudi.com
    http://www.chat-saudi.com

    ReplyDelete
  40. You can not expect an acrobatic monkey said after a training session, as well as one can not rely husbands know every dirty clean up after only one citation when he knew the correct pick up a sock
    geometry dash l baixar musicas gratis l retrica photo l play run 2 l b612 app l baixar snapchat

    ReplyDelete